Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Rock Vs Rap
Zack de la Rocha Network Forum > the 'burbs > .:: Zdlr.net Polls ::.
Pages: 1, 2
Renegades
I'm kinda curious to see how the mixture of rockers and hip hop heads differs on this site... cool.gif
regilas
^ You picked rap, right? I chose nothing, cuz I like em both as much.
rev79
Ren, you should've had a third option as the 'rap-rock' hybrid..I voted for rock, even though its about split down the middle these days for me.
Martyr
Im down with alot more hip hop than I used to be, and as far as what I listen to more, its pretty even, but no contest really. Rock, metal, classic rock...some folk...(anything with a guitar, really) I find alot easier to get into.
RunninFree
to be quit frank...i have a certain hatred for rap unsure.gif



don't hate me
regilas
^ I don't hate you .......... yet, anyway


Why do you hate rap?
TheShootingStar
Rock and Rap.. wink.gif
Renegades
I personally believe that Zack's solo album with be more hip hop based than rock, judging by the people he's collaborated with over the past few years. "March Of Death" had a rock-n-roll vibe, but essentially - it was still a DJ spinning the beat and not a guitar, bass and drum kit.

I think that a lot of Zack's fans on this site, who mightn't have heard tracks that Zack has released since he left RATM (other than "March Of Death") are expecting a more 'rock' project of some kind. I really don't think that this will happen. I've listened to the artists that Zack's collaborated with, and if he enjoys their music then I can't imagine he'd be going back to his "Inside Out" ways (I mean come on, that was 16 years ago!). Don't get me wrong, I reckon Zack will be angry on his album - but I also reckon he'll have a fair few chilled out tracks too.

I'm curious to see how this poll ends up, cause either way, some people on this site are probably not going to like the solo album. To me it's like the rockers look one way while the hip hoppers look another - but hopefully Zack tears the page down the middle.

blackhair.gif
regilas
^ I seriously believe that it'll be hip-hop based, cuz that's what it is, isn't it? Adding on to it, it's supposed to have a "scary" sound to it. This makes me think of a weirder version of March of Death. Still, rap or rock, I'll like it, cuz I like both. That's why I nulled my vote. wink.gif
RunninFree
QUOTE (regilas @ Jun 20 2004, 08:28 PM)
^ I don't hate you .......... yet, anyway


Why do you hate rap?

i dislike almost everything about it...i find the music..well stupid..i don't like d.j's effects and scratching...i like harder music to...stuff that gets me going kinda with awesome guitar solos rap can't really do that for me


hate me yet?
regilas
^ Yeah



No, I kid.



But rap isn't just plain stupid. The lyrics sometimes are stupid, yes. The arrangement of the music is also sometimes stupid, but that's sometimes the case with rock songs; how many rap songs do you know, anyway? Another question: how old are you?

I'm not trying to argue, just talking.
RunninFree
QUOTE (regilas @ Jun 21 2004, 07:06 PM)
^ Yeah



No, I kid.



But rap isn't just plain stupid. The lyrics sometimes are stupid, yes. The arrangement of the music is also sometimes stupid, but that's sometimes the case with rock songs; how many rap songs do you know, anyway? Another question: how old are you?

I'm not trying to argue, just talking.

i know alot of rap songs mainly cuz there overplayed on the radio and alot of my friends and other people at school are into rap

i just don't like it mainly cuz the music and alot of the lyrics are stupid...

i'm one year younger then you.

don't judge me from my age though..i dedicate all my time to music


also not trying to argue
TheShootingStar
QUOTE (regilas @ Jun 21 2004, 05:47 PM)
^ I seriously believe that it'll be hip-hop based, cuz that's what it is, isn't it? Adding on to it, it's supposed to have a "scary" sound to it. This makes me think of a weirder version of March of Death. Still, rap or rock, I'll like it, cuz I like both. That's why I nulled my vote. wink.gif

Well said Regilas, I agree.. smile.gif


Renegades....


I DEFINITELY think the album will be more hip hop based than Rock because Zack said it was going to be a hip hop album right??? Well, I won't totally rule out that there won't be any Rock on the album.. But, I think the album will be more Drum n Bass and Hip Hop mixed together than anything... ya know???

But, either way... I don't care if its more Rock or more Rap, or Hip Hop... I know I will enjoy it for sure.................








IF IT EVER COMES OUT!!!!!!! laughing.gif


regilas
QUOTE (RunninFree @ Jun 21 2004, 10:27 PM)
i know alot of rap songs mainly cuz there overplayed on the radio and alot of my friends and other people at school are into rap

i just don't like it mainly cuz the music and alot of the lyrics are stupid...

i'm one year younger then you.

don't judge me from my age though..i dedicate all my time to music


also not trying to argue

I can hardly play rap on the one station I know of, cuz it's low volume and it sorta sucks, anyway. Actually, I first got into rap thru RATM. After listening to it, I was way more open-minded about music than I had ever been. It opened both rap and rock for me, and got me into more than just that, but anyway.

The lyrics do get pretty bad, yeah. But what about Kid Rock? The one song I know of theirs completely sucks. No lyrics, just a bunch of weird sounds he keeps making. I've heard it thru MTV three times, and that's saying alot, considering I don't even have TV.

I'm not judging you by your age. I'd just like to know because I was 15 when I got into music. Before then, I was only into the Smashing Pumpkins. It's most likely that when you're 16, you're gonna be more varied in music than you are now. But then, I don't know you, so I don't really know.

And don't dedicate ALL of your time to music. There's more to do! I suppose not, though, considering you're only 15.
RunninFree
i hate kid rock to...and korn is what got me into music when i was 13. and seriously i love dedicating my time to music its something i really really love to do both listen and play.

oh well i'm just not ment to be a rap/hip hop fan

i'm also not a fan of pop, techno and alot of newer punk stuff

what i'm into is rock, hard rock, metal, some punk and i guess the whole "rock/rap" thing.


sorry this is off topic almost completly i just like talking tongue.gif
regilas
^ No it ain't (at least to me).


I'm into just about anything, except jazz.

Korn rocks! That's another band I sorta liked before hearing much of RATM. Ya like Tool?
RunninFree
i've never really listened to tool...i've heard songs but didn't pay much attention to them...perhaps i'll listen to them again soon


any good tool song suggestions?
Martyr
^ Start with the obvious...Sober, Schism, Prison Sex, Stinkfist...Aenema...
RunninFree
alright
RunninFree
hmm..i really like the music and stuff..and maynard has a nice voice but i don't think they go well together...and he just seems to repeat fuck alot...whats up with that?




reg you a fan of the misfits?
Holter
omg tool is awesome. respect the tool! hahaha

Im like addicted to the song the grudge right now. I bet that song would be unfuckingbelieveable live.
DTA
im addicted to sober my friend went to their concert and said they played it flawless. i love them.
regilas
I'm addicted to Eulogy and The Grudge, at the moment.


No, I've heard of Misfits, but never really heard any of their music.
Rain
Like both, but stating a preference was easy: I went with rock.
mushroomlife
Not enough choices up there..... I'm an all of the above kind of guy when it comes to music... all dependant on my mood at the time.... Tool and Misfits are both really great..... but ten minutes from now I could be on a Tori Amos kick.... few after fire up Wu Tang..... Mozart..... Irish traditional..... whatever..... I just go with what sounds good at the time..... and hey Reg, why no on the Jazz.... if you don't mind me asking that is....
letsgetreal
QUOTE (RunninFree @ Jun 22 2004, 05:32 PM)
i hate kid rock to...and korn is what got me into music when i was 13. and seriously i love dedicating my time to music its something i really really love to do both listen and play.

oh well i'm just not ment to be a rap/hip hop fan

i'm also not a fan of pop, techno and alot of newer punk stuff

what i'm into is rock, hard rock, metal, some punk and i guess the whole "rock/rap" thing.


sorry this is off topic almost completly i just like talking tongue.gif

Haha runninfree man, i agree with basically everything you said.
I dont hate rap, i actually have a fe records and like many songs, but i do hate today´s rap as i hear it in the radio, especially when i go to the United States. I also dislike the attitude that lots of rap singers have developed. In some cases it just turns out being lame and elitist, disrespectful.. trying to be "kewl". Bah... i hate "kewl" people. I know that not all the rap is about this though.

And YES, Kid Rock does suck! But ill have to target Eminem as the top of my hate list...


And new "punk" music (as in simple plan, good charlotte...) Good lord, they all suck (its just my opinion anyway)
regilas
I like Eminem mad.gif laughing.gif



Why no on the jazz? I hate it. Especially when I went to a college concert and heard the most horrible voice in California singing songs. Jazz seems like simply talking throughout the music. Rock keeps a rhythem(sp) going, and the lyrics go in with each other, and the singers carry a tune. For instance:

Rock song:
He had alot to say
He had alotta nothing to say
we'll miss him
we'll miss him
x2


Jazz song:
I'm going on the road to Indiana
when I stop by and ...

I hardly remember it, cuz the lyrics went by too quickly. Quicker than rap. Jazz also seems to have crappy beginnings and endings. It's as if the music switch was turned on for a while, then it was turned off again at the "end" of the song. It's like ending Know Your Enemy after Keenan's voice.

In conclusion: I hate jazz because of the overall. Once again, you may as well just talk during the song, cuz that's what jazz seems like. Those that sing in it may have good voices, but I simply think that those voices could use their talent on something else, maybe rock, or if they're more mellow, on folk-music.
mushroomlife
was just wondering..... thank you for replying....
RATMROXMYSOX
Gah! Can't take this...I like both equally! Although the people at my school can't tell at first... blackhair.gif I guess I don't look like the average hip-hop head persay...but screw `em! Screw them and their opinion! Judging me cuz I have orange bangs cry.gif Well yeah...their should be rap-rock up there...::sigh::
Manifest
Blues Sucka pimp2.gif
Renegades
Just for the record, Eminem likes Rage Against The Machine. He mentioned them in an article years back (The link is dead now... mad.gif ). He also mentions them in one of his songs called "Just Don't Give A Fuck".

As for rap being crap; you just need to know what to listen to. You generally won't find good rap on the radio. I'd say start with Run-DMC's greatest hits CD, you want political hip hop go KRS-One's "A Retrospective" or if you like mellow stuff go to De La Soul's "Stakes Is High". Also check out Blackalicious and A Tribe Called Quest. If you think that DJ's are all about break beats and scratching, get yourself a copy of DJ Shadow's "Endtroducing" album. Personally, this is what I predict Zack's album will come close to sounding like. I hope I've been helpful smile.gif
RunninFree
ahhh...you see renegades no matter how good the d.j and even if the rapper can talk super fast the music is just...well plain crap. the whole turntables and effect things just sound really stupid to me. i like guitars/bass and drums. i even hate keyboards. sure there hard instruments and i guess i respect the people who play them as much as a guitar player (sept in some cases) but i don't like the sound of the music.

sorry if my point doesn't seem clear its kinda hard to explain i guess
Renegades
It's cool, I suppose I cant understand. I hat the Misfits and all that other hard stuff though, too much for my ears... wink.gif
RunninFree
heh thats understandable tongue.gif
regilas
QUOTE (RunninFree @ Jul 4 2004, 10:10 PM)
ahhh...you see renegades no matter how good the d.j and even if the rapper can talk super fast the music is just...well plain crap. the whole turntables and effect things just sound really stupid to me. i like guitars/bass and drums. i even hate keyboards. sure there hard instruments and i guess i respect the people who play them as much as a guitar player (sept in some cases) but i don't like the sound of the music.

sorry if my point doesn't seem clear its kinda hard to explain i guess

Well, that's just your opinion. (Not attacking.)


Supposedly, though I have no source, cuz my brother Mantra (aka PsychoDeGrace) told me this. Anyway, he says that statistics showed in some article that more black people liked hip-hop and rap; and that more white people liked rock and metal.

It does sound true, but at the same time it sounds racist. unsure.gif
Renegades
Actually that doesn't suprise me at all! laughing.gif I mean, in America the rap genre is still very much African-American based. Most rappers are black over there. Rock was developed mostly in America and England from middle-class white kids, so it's understandable to see why that hasn't changed much either...
regilas
Yeah, that's what I thought, and I see it day after day. I dunno, it just seemed weird at the time. It feels normal, now, but ... I dunno, ya know.
T-Mac
of course i'll go with rap because 2pac isthe best singer ever touched the mic and no one will be better than him and he is the most record selling rapper with 27.5 million. that's it wavenew.gif
rage_mustang
QUOTE (T-Mac @ Jul 6 2004, 01:25 AM)
of course i'll go with rap because 2pac isthe best singer ever touched the mic and no one will be better than him and he is the most record selling rapper with 27.5 million. that's it wavenew.gif

You're right T-Mac.


And welcome to message board. Are you from istanbul? (ben bazen türkçe küfür ediyorum onlara smile.gif ) wavenew.gif clap2.gif w00t.gif

Symposi----I hope someone reads konusunun son 3 mesajina bak.
T-Mac
yes i am from istanbul

by the way i forgot to say welcome to y'all
Sara
touch my zz
Fanatical Radical
I preffer rock, from old to modern

I do like Rap though. Atmosphere, K-os, and Sweatshop Union are all some of my favorite artists. And amazing bands like RatM and Warsawpack mix elements from rap into their music.
Brn1337
How can you choose rock over rap when Zack did a little bit of both? dunno.gif
zack19709
yo i'd say that i prefer rock,hardcore and metal,but i have no problem listening to almost everything.for example i like doors,john lee hooker,black sabbath...,pantera,body count,slipknot,nirvana,children of bodom,or cypress hill,ice-t,dmx,ll cool j,n.w.a,public enemy,and of course the best band ever,ratm.i think what is important is to be open minded.of course i dont like pop or trance at all,but anyway.
T-Mac
QUOTE(zack19709 @ Jul 11 2004, 02:40 PM)
yo i'd say that i prefer rock,hardcore and metal,but i have no problem listening to almost everything.for example i like doors,john lee hooker,black sabbath...,pantera,body count,slipknot,nirvana,children of bodom,or cypress hill,ice-t,dmx,ll cool j,n.w.a,public enemy,and of course the best band ever,ratm.i think what is important is to be open minded.of course i dont like pop or trance at all,but anyway.
[right][snapback]119536[/snapback][/right]



do yo ulove 2Pac you know the legendary rapper
Nino
another pac fan on the forum laughing.gif

obviously you got to love tupac although i know a lot of people dont especially banksy ermm.gif
AllPowerToThePeople
I like rap, but I not knoe anithing about it, and I love Rock...
T-Mac
QUOTE(amaru @ Jul 12 2004, 02:02 PM)
another pac fan on the forum  laughing.gif

obviously you got to love tupac although i know a lot of people dont especially banksy  ermm.gif
[right][snapback]119787[/snapback][/right]



because he is the best wink.gif



Renegades
I reckon his family hell sold out on him by releasing all those unfinished songs, bootlegs and other crap just to cash in on him... sad.gif

2Pac is still very... grade 8 to me... unsure.gif
Banksy
QUOTE(amaru @ Jul 12 2004, 10:02 PM)
another pac fan on the forum  laughing.gif

obviously you got to love tupac although i know a lot of people dont especially banksy  ermm.gif
[right][snapback]119787[/snapback][/right]


I don't like what he sings about. I don't like his view on things or how he trys to portray himself. I also don't really like his voice to much either, It sounds to me very similar to lots of other rappers so I don't really see what makes him so special really.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2013 Invision Power Services, Inc.